Who are five potential Pro Bowlers for the Colts this year?

Here are five standouts who realistically could make the Pro Bowl for the Indianapolis Colts this year!

The Indianapolis Colts (6-7) haven’t had quite the season that many of the Horseshoe Faithful were ideally hoping for, but they still remain in realistic playoff contention—albeit now on the outside, looking in as they contend for a final AFC postseason spot.

Here are five candidates who could make a Pro Bowl for the Colts this season:

Photo by Cooper Neill/Getty Images

DeForest Buckner

Since arriving to Indianapolis via trade from San Francisco in 2020, the veteran defensive tackle has consistently been one of the Colts most valuable players during that same span.

Buckner missed five games because of a high ankle sprain, but he’s returned to being the Colts best defensive player once again. During 8 games (7 starts), Buckner has 44 tackles (19 solo), 6 tackles for loss, 5.5 sacks, and 11 QB hits.

Per PFF, his 82.6 overall grade is the 6th best among all interior defenders—which includes a +83.6 pass rushing grade (which is also 6th highest among players at his position).

The AFC is a bit crowded at defensive tackle though with the Kansas City Chiefs Chris Jones, the Pittsburgh Steelers Cam Heyward, and the New York Jets Quinnen Williams among other standouts within the conference.

Photo by Cooper Neill/Getty Images

Kenny Moore II

Having re-signed with Indianapolis this past offseason, the veteran cornerback remains one of the best slot coverage guys in the game. The former 2021 NFL Pro Bowler is putting up numbers that are worthy of such high recognition yet again.

Per PFF, Moore has a +80.3 overall grade, which is the 5th best among all players at his position, and is highlighted by a +79.4 coverage grade.

Slot corners tend to be docked a bit in all-star votes compared to their outside colleagues, but Moore is deserving of making his 2nd career Pro Bowl appearance after his strong performance.

His AFC cornerback competition figures to include the Denver Broncos Patrick Surtain II, the Los Angeles Chargers Tarheeb Still, the Baltimore Ravens Marlon Humphrey, and the Miami Dolphins Jalen Ramsey among others.

Photo by Cooper Neill/Getty Images

Quenton Nelson

The 6x NFL Pro Bowler hasn’t missed a Pro Bowl yet in his Canton-bound pro career, and Big Q is well deserving of such honors yet again—as the Colts catalyst along their offensive line.

While other starters have been in-and-out of the lineup all season, Nelson has been the one constant helping to anchor the left side—making all 13 starts.

Nelson’s +80.7 overall grade is 11th best at his position, and his pass blocking grade of +79.7 and run blocking grade of +83.0 which are 7th best at his position respectively.

His top competition includes the Kansas City Chiefs Joe Thuney and the Denver Broncos Quinn Meinerz among others.

Photo by Justin Casterline/Getty Images

Bernhard Raimann

While he’s missed some time because of injuries, the 3rd-year offensive tackle has made 10 starts as the blindside anchor for the Colts offensive line.

Since becoming a 2022 3rd round pick of the Colts, the only thing that Raimann has done has gotten consistently better as a left bookend for Indianapolis.

Per PFF, his +84.7 overall grade is the 8th best among all offensive tackles, which features a +85.1 pass blocking grade. Specifically, Raimann has allowed 3 sacks and 12 total QB pressures during 322 total pass blocking snaps.

His top peers at left tackle include the Miami Dolphins Terron Armstead, the Houston Texans Laremy Tunsil, the Los Angeles Chargers Rashawn Slater, and the Baltimore Ravens Ronnie Staley among others.

Photo by Fred Kfoury III/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

Grover Stewart

The 6’4,” 314 pound veteran run-stuffing nose tackle has 52 tackles (21 solo), 8 tackles for loss, 3.5 sacks, 2 passes defensed, and a forced fumble during 13 starts.

Per PFF, while Stewart’s +71.3 overall grade is solid but unspectacular (placing him as their 24th best graded interior defender), his run defense grade of +72.8 is nearly Top 10 (at 11th).

Stewart will never light up the box score with defensive counting stats, as a byproduct of commanding double teams inside. and shutting down the opponent’s run game, but his importance to the middle of the Colts defense—alongside Buckner, can’t be understated.