Ranking 19 offensive line prospects in the 2025 NFL Draft

It’s draft season! I’ve been busy watching many of these prospects, so in the lead-up to the 2025 NFL Draft, I’ll release my Eagles-specific rankings. Before you read ahead, please keep in mind the following!

1. I have ranked these players based on the Eagles’ needs and scheme fits. Therefore, I may rank player ‘X’ above player ‘Y’ in terms of pure talent and my own personal rankings, but due to the Eagles’ needs and scheme fit, I have player ‘Y’ above player ‘X’.
2. Please focus more on the tiers rather than the exact numerical order. I use tiers when I have similar grades on players, and there might not be a lot of difference between players if they are in the same tier.
3. I may mention off-the-field and injury issues in the reports, but I don’t factor that in when ranking these prospects. We don’t have the necessary information.
4. If I haven’t ranked someone, I haven’t watched them! If you’d like me to watch someone in particular, feel free to comment, and I’ll try to get to them before the draft.

You can check out my podcast feed here to hear more from me. Also, I have released an Eagles-specific Draft Guide on my Patreon, which will include more information on each player.

Previously: Running Back / Wide Receiver / Tight End

Offensive Line

Tier 1

1. Armand Membou, Missouri, 6-4 1/4 332

Overall: Membou is a physically gifted and explosive right tackle who started 30 straight games at Missouri and didn’t allow a sack in his final season. While his build suggests a potential move inside, he plays with enough length, toughness, and refined technique to succeed at tackle or guard. He has raw power, quick feet, and a finisher’s mindset. He’s going to be a good pro!

Eagles Thoughts: In my dreams!

2. Josh Simmons, Ohio State, 6-4 7/8 317

Overall: Josh Simmons is a fluid, athletic offensive tackle with quick feet, good hands, and strong pass-blocking ability. He excels when asked to move in space and has proven he can play both left and right tackle at a high level. While not a dominant run blocker and coming off a serious knee injury, his natural tools give him the upside of the best lineman in this class.

Eagles Thoughts: I would love this, but he’s going way too early.

3. Will Campbell, LSU, 6-5 7/8 319

Overall: Will Campbell is a highly athletic, technically sound left tackle with a rare mix of physicality, poise, and quickness. However, he has a significant issue with his anchor, which could be linked to his short arms. His short arms and occasional pad level issues may limit his ceiling on the edge. Whether he stays at left tackle or shifts inside, Campbell projects as a long-term starter.

Eagles Thoughts: I’m lower on Campbell than the consensus, but he’s going in the top 10.

Tier 2

4. Kelvin Banks Jr, Texas, 6-5 1/8 315

Overall: Kelvin Banks is an athletic, technically sound left tackle with good pass protection fundamentals and fluid movement skills. While he thrives in space and shows high football IQ, his lack of length and ability to sustain blocks in the run game remain big concerns. He projects as an early NFL starter, though his long-term home might be inside at guard. However, he’s never played there!

Eagles Thoughts: I think Banks could end up falling to 32, and I would expect the Eagles to be interested. He has the movement skills that the Eagles look for. He needs a lot of coaching, but the Eagles can give him outstanding coaching! He might start at RG and possibly (although unlikely) end up as a future tackle.

5. Tyler Booker, Alabama, 6-4 5/8 321

Overall: Booker is a throwback, people-moving guard built like a tank with the anchor and mindset to punish defenders. He’s a tone-setter. However, he has severe athletic limitations that I imagine will cause some teams not even to have him on their boards. You need to have a clear plan on how to use him.

Eagles Thoughts: I think the Eagles may be one of the teams that value Tyler Booker. Although his lack of athleticism is a major red flag, the Eagles might decide they have enough athleticism around Booker (Cam Jurgens/Lane Johnson) to cover his flaws. If the Eagles want to commit to a physical downhill running game behind Saquon Barkley, you won’t find a more physically dominant guard than Tyler Booker. I’ve got no idea where he will go, but I think the Eagles will have interest if he is there at pick 32.

6. Grey Zabel, N. Dakota St. 6-5 7/8 312

Overall: Zabel is a versatile lineman with excellent movement skills and elite football intelligence. While his lack of length and anchor strength will push him inside, his athleticism and hand strength give him a clear path to succeed on the interior. He could be an outstanding center, and maybe a great guard?

Eagles Thoughts: If the Eagles think he can play right guard… watch out at 32. He’s the opposite style to Mekhi Becton, but the Eagles played with Cam Jurgens next to Jason Kelce before, so they are happy with two quick interior linemen!

7. Josh Conerly Jr. Oregon. 6-4 5/8 311

Overall: Josh Conerly is a highly athletic, fluid left tackle with outstanding foot quickness. He thrives in space as a puller and second-level blocker, but his core strength and hand technique must improve to handle NFL power. Though slightly undersized and raw in certain areas, he offers upside as a very good tackle.

Eagles Thoughts: I can absolutely see the Eagles having interest in Conerly at 32. I can’t see him having the anchor to kick inside, so it would be a selection as a future tackle, which I wouldn’t love. He has the movement skills that Jeff Stoutland will love! I don’t like taking a tackle who needs a ton of work at 32, but the Eagles might decide the upside is too high to pass. I can’t see him kicking inside to guar,d as I think he needs to develop as a tackle.

Tier 3

8. Donovan Jackson, Ohio State, 6-3 5/8 315

Overall: Donovan Jackson is a well-built lineman with over 50 games of experience and the football IQ to start in the NFL. While not a dominant mauler, his anchor and steady hands in pass pro make him a reliable guard with possible tackle flexibility.

Eagles Thoughts: I think he will be a guard in the league, and I imagine the Eagles see him as a guard too, but could be intrigued by his tackle versatility (as they were with Tyler Steen). I guess 32 is too early, and I’m unsure of his upside, but he would be an outstanding 2nd-round pick. He would compete with Steen at RG and provide a backup across multiple positions. I could see the Eagles having interest in him early in the 2nd round.

9. Tate Ratledge, Georgia, 6-6 1/2 308

Overall: Ratledge is a physical interior right guard with NFL-level play strength, quick eyes, and a physical play style that shows up especially well against power. Though he lacks ideal length and has mostly played only right guard, he makes up for it with the quickness and athleticism to reset and recover within the rep. If he stays healthy, Ratledge projects as a dependable starting right guard.

Eagles Thoughts: If the Eagles want to draft a starting right guard in the 2nd round, Ratledge makes a ton of sense. I think he’s going to be a solid starter, but due to his arm length, he doesn’t have elite upside.

10. Aireontae Ersery, Minnesota, 6-6 1/4 331

Overall: Aireontae Ersery is a massive, athletic tackle with a powerful punch, natural size, and good movement skills. If he can clean up his hand usage, strike timing, and redirect ability, he has all the tools to develop into a long-term NFL starter — but he’ll need time and coaching.

Eagles Thoughts: If he is available towards the Eagles’2nd round pick, I wouldn’t be shocked to see a trade up for Ersery. He’s a great athlete who needs good coaching to develop into a future starting tackle. I think 32 would be too early.

11. Jonah Savaiinaea, Arizona, 6-4 1/8 324

Overall: Savaiinaea is a well-built, competitive lineman with starter-caliber tools out of the gate. While he has held up at guard and tackle in college, his physical profile and skill set project best to guard, where he can stay square and rely less on lateral quickness. He may not be an immediate run game mauler, which limits his upside, but he has enough size and ability to start early.

Eagles Thoughts: I think Savaiinaea could step in and start at right guard immediately, but I didn’t see the dominance in the run game that the Eagles will value. He has the size the Eagles look for, so they could have interest in the 2nd, but I have a feeling they may want more of a mauler. However, he has tackle/guard versatility and a massive frame – this sounds familiar!

Tier 4

12. Charles Grant, William & Mary, 6-4 7/8 311

Overall: Charles Grant is a high-upside developmental tackle with good movement skills for his size. His lack of bulk and limited experience against top-tier pass rushers suggest he may need a redshirt year, but his athleticism and football IQ are evident in how smoothly he operates in space. Grant has the makings of a starting-caliber tackle. He could kick inside to guard, too.

Eagles Thoughts: The Eagles are absolutely going to have interest in Grant if he is there in the 3rd round. They can give him a year to develop and build out his frame. It’s possible he could play at guard if needed, too. The Eagles brought him in for a visit, and if they are happy with his athleticism and movement skills, I could see the Eagles trading up for him in the 3rd.

13. Cameron Williams, Texas, 6-5 3/4 317

Overall: A one-year starter, Cameron Williams possesses ideal physical traits, including length, power, and athleticism. However, he struggles with technique, particularly in hand placement and footwork, which often leads to balance issues and penalties. Williams could develop into a starter down the road, though patience will be required.

Eagles Thoughts: An athletic lineman with physical traits that badly needs coaching? That sounds like Jeff Stoutland’s music. I just wish we had testing numbers, but he was injured. He could compete at guard or develop at tackle. I like this in the 3rd round.

14. Anthony Belton, NC State, 6-6 336

Overall: Belton is a massive, physical tackle with rare size and brute strength, but his inconsistent technique and limited agility cap his ceiling. While he can dominate at the point of attack, his footwork and hand placement can allow quicker rushers to get after him. He projects as a developmental T/G swing option with starting potential.

Eagles Thoughts: I’m not sure he has the juice to play tackle for the Eagles, but we know the Eagles love giant guards who can move defenders at the line of scrimmage! I imagine they will see Belton as someone who could play similarly to Mekhi Becton. I could see them taking a shot in the 3rd.

15. Marcus Mbow, Purdue, 6-4 1/8 303

Overall: Mbow is a quick-footed lineman with the movement skills and hand technique to become a good pass protector, especially on the interior. He lacks ideal bulk and strength to hold up against NFL power rushers consistently right away. He’ll need time to develop his strength and could grow into a valuable, versatile lineman. The arm length suggests he may fare better inside.

Eagles Thoughts: I’m not sure what to do with Mbow. He profiles as a tackle, and doesn’t have the physicality to be a mauler inside, but his 32’ arm length is a big concern. I think I see him as a backup for multiple positions, which has value in the 3rd round.

16. Ozzy Trapilo, Boston College, 6-8 1/8 316

Overall: Trapilo is a technically sound, experienced offensive tackle with starting reps at both tackle spots and strong hand usage, footwork, and mental processing. Though he lacks overwhelming power in the run game, his clean pass sets and high IQ will appeal to teams that want to throw the football a lot.

Eagles Thoughts: If the Eagles want a backup tackle to develop and replace Fred Johnson’s role as the backup tackle, the Eagles might be interested in Trapilo! He’s a long athlete who is a proper tackle. My issue is that he looks like a true pass protector, and the Eagles run the ball a lot. They might want someone with a bit more ‘dog’ in them.

17. Wyatt Milum West, Virginia, 6-6 1/2 313

Overall: A four-year starter, Wyatt Milum has showcased strong hands and physicality in both the run and pass games. While he has solid anchor strength and good processing ability, his upright pad level and lack of ideal lateral quickness limit his effectiveness against more skilled pass rushers. He has played right and left tackle, but will likely end up as a guard.

Eagles Thoughts: I like the way that Wyatt Milum competes. He’s not the elite athlete that the Eagles usually target, but he makes sense in the 3rd round, where he could either compete at right guard or develop as a backup tackle.

18. Miles Frazier, LSU, 6-5 5/8 317

Overall: Frazier is a tough, experienced lineman with the mass, power, and savvy to hold up inside. He tested extremely well, but struggles to handle twitcher rushers, and he will have to make up for it with physicality, awareness, and active hands. He profiles as a dependable NFL depth piece with the potential to develop into a starting guard.

Eagles Thoughts: If the Eagles want someone that can come in and challenge Steen as the starting right guard as a rookie, Frazier makes sense in the 3rd round. He could even be useful as a backup tackle if needed, too.

19. Jared Wilson, Georgia, 6-3 310

Overall: Wilson is an athletic, high-upside center prospect who. Though still raw with just 12 starts and some inconsistencies in technique, if he stays healthy and continues to refine his base and control, he could develop into a very strong center.

Eagles Thoughts: I doubt the Eagles have interest in a center-only prospect unless they think he can possibly play guard.

As always, thank you for reading. If you want more detailed notes on each player (including strengths and weaknesses), then please check out the Draft Guide via Patreon.